Broadway Mini-Reviews
Presented by: Various
Venue: Various

Reviewer: Simon Parris
Date Reviewed: Dec 12 - 27, 2007

One of our most regular reviewers, Simon has appeared in more than 30 productions over the past twenty years. Recent roles include Uncle Henry/Guard of the Gate in The Wizard of Oz (Catchment) and Eugene Fodor in
Crazy for You (Whitehorse). Other favourite roles include Mr Fox in Mack and Mabel, Max in The Sound of Music, Freddy in My Fair Lady, Julio in Paint Your Wagon, Marcellus in The Music Man and Grantaire in Les Miserables.
In 2005, Simon was nominated for a Guild Award in the category Best Cameo Performance for his role as
the Judge in Hello, Dolly! (Whitehorse).

He is also a supremely keen audience member of all kinds of theatre, travelling biannually to both New York and London to take in well over 50 shows during the trip. This makes Simon the perfect advisor on ‘What to See’ and ‘What Not to See’ on the world’s greatest stages. During his latest sojourn, he prepared the following Mini-Reviews for our reading pleasure and as tips and hints for those about to set off to the Big Apple themselves.

 

 Ratings System

««««« Book your plane ticket

«««« A must see on your list

««« Worth seeing

««    Not up to Broadway standards

« If you get given a ticket, don’t go

Note: Many of the productions listed below have been reviewed by this site before. The following reviews take in the current casts of the productions at December 2007

 

Curtains (Kander & Ebb) ««««

Good old fashioned musical fun with an all star Broadway cast ­­- Tony winner David Hyde-Pierce, Debra Monk, Karen Ziemba, Jason Danieley and soon-to-be-‘Scarlett-O'Hara’, Jill Paice - all at the top of their game. Will be great for amateur companies sometime soon.

 


How The Grinch Stole Christmas! ««

Fun for kids. A one-act money-making machine that plays 15 times a week. (Closed Jan 6)

 
 


Wicked «««««

Stephanie J Block (‘Elphaba’) is brilliant. The audience nearly tore apart the theatre when she did not come out for the bows - turned out someone stepped on her hand in a slight change of blocking, very painful!

 

 


The Drowsy Chaperone «««

So much fun and so appropriate for me - hope I can play ‘Man in Chair’ one day - if I don't play him already every day. Cindy Williams (‘Shirley’ from Laverne & Shirley) was under-rehearsed - that's my polite term - as ‘Mrs Tottendale’. Bob Saget (Full House) was ok as ‘Man in Chair’. Original ‘Man in Chair’, Bob Martin was there and I got my photo with him!  (Closed Dec 30)

Simon with Bob Martin


A Chorus Line «««

Brilliant to see this on Broadway. Loved how the audience reacted to where the dancers where from - never thought of this angle before. Charlotte d'Amboise brought the house down as ‘Cassie’.
 


Make Me A Song ««

Revue of William Finn songs. No Spelling Bee songs but a great Falsettos section. (Closed Dec 30)

 


August: Osage County (by Tracy Letts) «««««

Absolutely brilliant three-act, three and a half hour play that will win the Tony and probably the Pulitzer. An extended family reunites when the patriarch goes missing. Edge of the seat drama with some necessary laughs and amazing performances, it seems to go by in minutes. Just extended 5 weeks to mid April.
 


Young Frankenstein «

The combined talents Mel Brooks, Susan Stroman, Roger Bart, Megan Mullaly, Sutton Foster and many others cannot save this from being an embarrassing turkey. Very few laughs, completely uninspired choreography and hopelessly forgettable songs. Schuler Hensley (The Monster), Andrea Martin (Frau Blucher), Christopher Fitzgerald (Igor) and Sutton Foster (Inga) acquit themselves quite well. I will never again book more than one ticket to a show before seeing it!

 

Simon with Sutton Foster


Legally Blonde ««««

More fun than it should be *legally* possible to have in the theatre. Snappy pace, catchy songs, fun chorey, cute designs. Laura Bell Bundy carries the show like a megastar.

 

 


Laura Bell Bundy with Simon


Gypsy of the Year (unrated - annual event)

Annual 'Red Faces' for the chorus members of Broadway, plus announcement of fundraising winners. The highlight was the 50 year reunion of the original cast of West Side Story. Chita Rivera, Carol Lawrence and many others (supplemented by a Follies-like younger ensemble) performed ‘A Boy Like That’, ‘Dance at the Gym’, ‘America’ and more.  


Forbidden Broadway: Rude Awakening «««

Always hilarious. Always heaps of new material.

 
 


The Homecoming (by Harold Pinter)  «««

Not really my cup of tea but I love Raul Esparza.


The Color Purple «««

Always heartwarming. Still doing solid business, although it will drop off a bit now American Idol winner, Fantasia has left on Jan 6.

 

 

 


The Little Mermaid «««

Really gorgeous designs, great score, strong cast but the whole affair falls strangely flat - there is no tension or drive to the story. Will do well with families though. The only other new musical (along with Young Frankenstein) to open in this half of the year so the Best Musical section in the Tony Awards is looking a bit sparse at this stage (Xanadu not withstanding.)

 


Cyrano de Bergerac ««««

Kevin Kline, Jennifer Garner and Daniel Sunjata lead a large (by Broadway standards) cast. Very enjoyable and ultimately quite moving. Jen wore some gorgeous frocks!

 

 

 Jennifer Garner


Spring Awakening«««««

I loved this show and was very glad to see it twice. Sensational young cast, gorgeous score, moving story and the most beautiful lighting on Broadway. I hope it comes to Australia.

 




 
Jonathan Groff with Simon


Xanadu ««««

More great fun. One-act, tongue-in-cheek, non-stop action and addictive, retro songs by ELO. Fabulous stars, Kerry Butler and Cheyenne Jackson are given brilliant comic support by Mary Testa and Jackie Hoffman. 

 


 


November (by David Mamet) ««««

An absolutely hilarious new play with a tour de force performance from Nathan Lane as a US President facing the prospect of not being re-elected. How much money can he get from threatening to pardon all the turkeys in America just before Thanksgiving, opening an Indian casino or being Best Man at his lesbian assistants wedding?

 


 
Nathan Lane with Simon


Mary Poppins ««««

Slightly improved from the London production, so it's even more gorgeous and magical than it already was. Ashley Brown was inexplicably replaced as Mary in act two.

 

 


Also, if you’re interested, the operas: (these shows are unrated due to the difference in comparison with opera programmes)

Hansel & Gretel

Totally inappropriate for the family market the advertising is aimed at. Dark and spooky - even I was scared when the witch was burned alive in the oven; I don't know how kiddies would cope!

A Masked Ball

The most stunning event on stage I have ever seen. You could feel the force of the strength of the singing. Amazing.

 

Coming soon... West End Mini-Reviews

 

BROADWAY TIPS by Mark Dooley
 

  • Use TKTS of course. There are 2 booths; one is usually in Times Square, but has been relocated while Duffy Square (the island it’s situated on) is being renovated. Temporarily it is in the Marriot Marquis Hotel, which is on West 46th Street, between Broadway and 8th Avenue. There’s also a TKTS at South Street Seaport, which is in the Financial District of Lower Manhattan. Tickets on the day of performance only. On Saturdays, you can also book for Sunday matinees.
  • Sign up to www.playbill.com - great discounts on most shows.
  • Lottery. You write your name down a couple of hours before a show, and the names are drawn out half an hour later. Not all shows offer this option. Wicked, Avenue Q and Jersey Boys do though. Tickets are usually sold for no more than $25 cash and seats are in the front row of the stalls. Bargain.
  • Book tickets before you leave home for the popular shows on the weekend. You will have a better chance of getting great seats to less popular shows, during weekdays.
  • Great Broadway hotels are St James Hotel or The Milford Plaza; both half a block walk from Times Square.
  • Broadway CDs – J & R Music World located at Park Row across from City Hall Park www.jr.com. Ask the staff to match their internet prices (thanks for the tip Simon Parris), and you will save a fortune. Do your research before you leave. Note: J&R don’t ship to Australia, so you’re still best off sticking with Amazon if you can’t save on shipping by picking them up in person!

 

Back To Reviews