The Phantom of the Opera
Presented by: The Really Useful Group Asia Pacific and The Gordon Frost Organisation
Venue:
The Princess Theatre, Melbourne
Reviewer: Simon Parris
Date Reviewed: 28th July 2007

It is difficult for the Generation Y (or younger) theatre-goer to fully appreciate the phenomenon of The Phantom of the Opera in the mid-1980s. The closest show in popularity today is probably Wicked. Imagine, however, if instead of just being imported by music theatre aficionados, the soundtrack was in every music store, the album was number one on the charts and the songs were in frequent rotation on the radio and even on music video programs.

It must also be kept in mind that while this is the third visit to Melbourne for The Phantom of the Opera, it has been playing continuously in London and New York since before it first opened here. It is currently the longest running musical on Broadway, having overtaken Cats in January 2006.

Tickets for the original Australian production, which premiered in Melbourne in December 1990, went on sale over a year in advance. Excitement grew during that year as promising young tenor Anthony Warlow became a superstar as Enjolras in Les Misérables and was cast as the Phantom.

Jaded musical theatre fans could see the return of Phantom as purely a money making exercise by the producers. With a very strong fan base providing a ready audience, the name alone could sell thousands of tickets. Happily, any doubts as to the financial and artistic effort put into this staging are swept aside as the show opens with the massive sets and jewelled costumes just as eye-popping as ever. A first-rate cast and dedicated production team have combined to make this show as fresh, dazzling and entertaining as the first production.

Some of the stars of the original production were not those seen on stage but were the designers at the height of their powers. Maria Björnson (who passed away five years ago) filled the stage with lush curtains that ebbed and flowed to mask, reveal and frame the action. An amazing number of ‘opera’ and ‘opera house’ scenes are used, all with a gothic and larger than life quality that has been a significant aspect in the success of the show.

Andrew Bridge’s lighting design is all the more remarkable for the blackouts that are achieved given the glossy black floor. Again, a clear contrast is established between behind the scenes and on-stage action. Martin Levan’s sound design has been re-created by Shelly Lee. An outstanding feature of the sound design was the work in Prima Donna where every significant phrase sung by each of seven characters singing at once was highlighted to be perfectly clear to the audience.

Love or hate Andrew Lloyd Webber, it is hard to argue with the success of Phantom of the Opera, possibly his most ambitious score. It is difficult to think of a more lush, melodious opening sequence of songs than Think of Me, Angel of Music, Phantom of the Opera and The Music of the Night. Further power ballads include the gloriously romantic All I Ask of You and the haunting Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again. The real triumph in the score comes not just from these tunes but from the witty opera pastiches, which are written in three distinct styles. Also, Prima Donna is an amazing septet that rivals Rossini for complexity and glorious resolution. Another masterstroke is the Phantom’s final note in The Music of the Night, which is held against a series of dissonant minor harmonies before finally resolving in a major chord.

Associate director Arthur Masella has somehow enhanced Hal Prince’s original direction so that the story telling is clearer than ever. Vanessa Scammell maintained the orchestra’s energy throughout the exhausting through-sung score. The effect of the Trumpeting Elephant was particularly pleasing.

Anthony Warlow has made a triumphant return to his signature role in this third production of The Phantom of the Opera. John Bowles, from the second Melbourne season, returns as Raoul. Fellow returning stars include John O’May, again playing Monsieur Firmin, and Derek Taylor, who has been promoted from Monsieur Reyer to Monsieur Andre.

It is almost an understatement to say that Anthony Warlow is in magnificent form as the Phantom. His tremendous experience in the role allows every nuance and inflection to be perfectly realised. With a reported 20 minutes on stage, the actor portraying the Phantom must establish a complex character that will horrify the audience whilst also gaining their empathy. This is fully achieved, with the final sequence in particular being suspenseful and ultimately extremely moving. Warlow uses his delicate falsetto and booming baritone to great effect.

Relative newcomer Ana Marina is a delight as Christine. Breathless, wide-eyed and vibrant throughout, she really excels when she finally has the stage to herself in Wishing You Were Somehow Here Again. Christine’s anguish over the Phantom’s final ultimatum is palpable and adds significantly to the drama of the climax. John Bowles, a veritable Peter Pan of musical theatre, is tall, dashing and impossibly youthful as Raoul. Bowles is in fine voice and presents a characterisation of Raoul that is thankfully more romantic and dashing than insipid.

New Zealand opera singer Andrea Creighton was born to play Carlotta. She was a clear audience favourite. David Rogers-Smith was suitably bombastic, indignant and short-sighted as the ill-fated Piangi. John O’May and Derek Taylor lent further comic support as Firmin and Andre. Jackie Rees was a commanding presence as Madame Giry. The distinctive outline of Rees’ face in the severe black costume was striking. Nadia Komazec, only 18 years old, rounded out the cast as the lively Meg.

This production of The Phantom of the Opera is a must for long-term fans and newcomers alike. Attendance is highly recommended – if you are lucky enough to get a ticket.

Bookings are at Ticketek:http://premier.ticketek.com.au/shows


Simon has appeared in more than 30 productions over the past twenty years. Recent roles include Eugene Fodor in Crazy for You (Whitehorse) and Mr Fox in Mack and Mabel (CLOC). Other favourite roles include Max in The Sound of Music, Freddy in My Fair Lady, Julio in Paint Your Wagon, Marcellus in The Music Man and Grantaire in Les Miserables. In 2005, Simon was nominated for a Guild Award in the category Best Cameo Performance for his role as the Judge in Hello, Dolly! (Whitehorse).

Simon is also a keen audience member, having seen over 50 shows in five weeks on a recent trip to New York and London. Simon has served on the Music Theatre Guild of Victoria Committee for three years, and is currently Treasurer.

 

Back To Reviews